How to Pick the Right Contractor in Toronto (Without Getting Burned)

Thinking of doing a few upgrades around the house? Maybe the kitchen’s stuck in 2004, the bathroom tiles are one cracked grout line away from becoming a tripping hazard, or you’ve finally had enough of that popcorn ceiling.
Whatever the reason — whether you're selling soon or just sick of looking at the same old cabinets — choosing the right contractor in Toronto is a big deal. And if you’re new to the game, don’t worry — I’ve got your back.

Here’s a down-to-earth guide with some real talk to help you avoid the flakes, phonies, and fly-by-nighters.

🔍 Step 1: Know What You Actually Need

This one’s important. Before you start calling people, figure out what kind of reno you’re really doing.
Are you:

• Just doing a facelift? (paint, lights, trim — that kind of thing)
• Replacing outdated finishes and fixtures?
• Going full HGTV, sledgehammer and all?

Not all contractors do everything — and some say they do, but shouldn’t. If someone tells you they do roofing, plumbing, tiling, and landscaping...run.

💡 Tyson Tip: Even small upgrades can go a long way — especially in older Toronto homes. A fresh coat of paint, new light fixtures, and swapping old hardware can totally change the vibe.

🧰 Step 2: Ask for Recommendations (from People You Trust)

The best place to start is still good ol’ word-of-mouth.
Ask your:

• Friends, family, or neighbours who’ve recently had work done
• Real estate agent (hi 🙋‍♂️)
• Community groups (Toronto Reddit, Facebook neighbourhood groups, etc.)

If they rave about someone and you love the work, that’s worth a follow-up. But don’t stop there…

🌐 Step 3: Stalk Them Online (In a Non-Creepy Way)

Welcome to the review rabbit hole. You’ll want to see what other people are saying — and more importantly, what they’re not saying.

Good places to check:

• HomeStars
• TrustedPros
• Better Business Bureau
• Google Reviews

Look for patterns. Is everyone thrilled? Do they show up on time? Stick to the budget? Are they ghosts after the deposit clears?

🚩 Red flag alert: If the reviews are too glowing and generic — like “Bob is amazing. I love Bob. Bob is best.” — they might be fake.

📝 Step 4: Interview a Few — Like It’s Speed Dating, But for Drywall

Even if you think you found “the one,” talk to at least two or three contractors. Ask questions. See how they vibe. Are they knowledgeable? Do they seem rushed? Defensive? Confused about what a backsplash is?

Ask them:

• “Do you have photos of recent work?”
• “Are you insured and covered by WSIB?”
• “Do you handle permits or will I need to?”
• “How long will this actually take — really?”

You’re not being annoying — you’re being smart.

💵 Step 5: Get Quotes… and Not Just in Text Message Form

A real quote should break things down:

• Materials vs. labour
• Timelines
• Who’s responsible for what
• Any extras or surprises they foresee

A lowball price might sound great, but corners will be cut. Or timelines will drag. Or both. And if someone asks for more than 15% upfront… walk.

You want fair, transparent, and clear. Not “I know a guy” energy.

📸 Step 6: Get It in Writing, Every Time

No matter how nice they seem, always get a written contract. It should include:

• Clear scope of work
• Materials list (with brands/finishes if possible)
• Payment schedule
• What happens if things go sideways
• Warranty or touch-ups after completion

Take before/after pics, too — not just for Instagram, but in case anything needs to be revisited later.

🧠 Final Thoughts (aka: Real Talk)

Toronto is one of the biggest, busiest real estate markets in the world. We’ve got old Victorians, weird layouts, knob-and-tube surprises, laneway oddities — you name it. So don’t hire someone just because they did your cousin’s deck in Brampton.

Be picky. Ask questions. Trust your gut. And remember, a good contractor won’t just make your place look amazing — they’ll make the whole process feel (mostly) stress-free.

Bonus Tip: Can’t decide? Try this:

• Ask if you can chat with a recent client
• Look at before and after pics from similar projects
• Check how long they’ve been in business (if they’ve been around 10+ years in Toronto and still have good reviews, that’s a good sign)

Got questions? Want a printable checklist? Thinking about which renos get the most bang for your buck? I’ve got blogs on that too — or feel free to reach out.

I’m always happy to help fellow Torontonians make smart moves at home — renovations included. 🛠️🏡

‍